Diagramming

Disclaimer: the below table is a work in progress and can be used "as is" as! Project's objective is to identify the sources for the various means of diagramming invented over the years (uncertain years were marked with a "*"). 

Period Author(s) Title Description Region
500 BC* Simonides of Ceos
• earliest usage of "mental images" (as reported by Cicero [#], see mental models) Greek
320 BC* Plato "Ion", "The Republic" (books II, III & X1) • earliest usage of "mimesis", close to image or representation as meaning Greek
350 BC* Aristotle "Prior Analytics" • proposed a syllogistic system of reasoning in which a logical argument where a quantified statement of a specific form (the conclusion) is inferred from two other quantified statements (the premises)
• used schemata of deduction
Greek
350 BC*Aristotle "De Anima" ("On the Soul")• phantasmata ([#], see mental models)
Greek



 


 
2nd c. BC
• Phaistos clay disc with radial structure Greek
55 BC Marcus Tullius Cicero "De Oratore" • speaks of Simonides of Ceos who developed a system of mnemonics based on (mental) images and places called the 'method of loci' Latin
3rd c. Porphyry of Tyre Tree of Porphyry • illustrates Aristotle's classification of categories into a tree-like fashion called also a ‘scale of being’ [link]
• the oldest known semantic network
Greek

 
 

5th c.
The Great Stemma • combination of a timeline and 15 family trees that represents the progression of generations mentioned in the Bible, from Adam and Eve, to Christ [2] Latin
520* Anicius Manlius Severinus Boethius "Isagogen Porphyrii Commentum" • version of Arbor Porphyriana Latin
562* Magnus Aurelius Cassiodorus • graphical representation of the outline of the Bible [2] Latin
 
 
1239 Peter of Spain (aka Petrus Hispanus) "Summulae Logicales" • logical hierarchy with aristotelian categories represented knowledge by genus Spain
1268* St. Thomas Aquinas "De Anima" • commentaries on Aristotle's De Anima Italy
1350 Ramon Llull "Ars Magna" • first logic machine constructed to answer spiritual questions
• "earliest attempt in the history of formal logic to employ geometrical diagrams for the purpose of discovering nonmathematical truths, and the first attempt to use a mechanical device - a kind of primitive logic machine - to facilitate the operation of a logic system." [1]
Spain
Leornado Davinci
• 
1175* Usama ibn Munqidh "Book of Contemplation" Syria
 

1509 Thomas Murner "Logica Memorativa" • provides mnemonic strategies for the student to learn logic quickly
1527 Dante Alighieri "Divine Comedy" • edition published by Panganino & Alessandro Paganini includes a ‘moral schema of Hell’, grouping sinners according to theological and moral concepts Italy
1586 Stevin "De weedgaet"
1641 René Descartes "Meditations" II France
1651 Thomas Hobbes "Leviathan: The Matter, Form and Power of a Commonwealth Ecclesiastical and Civil" England
1664? d’Anguerrande "Treatise on the virtues of excellence, and how one may acquire them." • use of radiant organization of nodes, color and single-word branches (similar to Buzan mind mappers) [2]
1666 Gottfried W Leibnitz "Dissertio de arte combinatoria" • constructs an exhaustive table of all possible combinations of premises and conclusions in the traditional syllogism. German
 
1661 Johann C Sturm "Universalia Euclidea" • uses circles for representing actual class propositions and syllogisms [1] German
1669 Athanasius Kircher "Ars magna sciendi sive combinatoria. • first visual organiser German

Isaac Newton
• came close to originating concept maps [2] England
1678 John Bunyan "Pilgrim’s Progress" • visual organizer on religious thematic
1686 Gottfried W Leibniz "Discourse on Metaphysics" German
1688 Nicolas Malebranche "Dialogues On Metaphysics And Religion" French
1712 Johann Christian Lange "Nucleus logicae Weisianae" • uses circles for representing actual class propositions and syllogisms [1]
• "a geometrical system that will not only represent class statements and syllogisms in a highly isomorphic manner, but also can be manipulated for the actual solution of problems in class logic" [1]
German
 
1738 David Hume "Treatise of Human Nature", England
1761 Leonhard Euler "Lettres d'une Princesse d'Allemagne", Vol. 2, 1772, letters 102 to 108. Swiss
 

1764 Johann Heinrich Lambert "Neues Organon" • linear method of diagraming, closely allied to the Euler circles Swiss
 

1781 Immanuel Kant "Critique of Pure Reason" • introduction of "schema" German
 
 
1800 Charles Stanhope "The Science of Reasoning Clearly Explained upon New Principles" unpublished • "logic demonstrator" device (described in Rev. Robert Harley, "The Stanhope Demonstrator", Mind, Vol. 4, April, 1879) England
 
 
 
1802 Immanuel Kant "Physische Geographie" ["Physical Geography"] • first indirect reference to a "mental model" like concept German
1837 Charles R Darwin • first thoughts of an evolutionary tree of life that shows notionally the relationships that he was beginning to feel might exist among species [1] England
1846 William Hamilton • "quantification of the predicate" England
1854 George Boole • presented his laws of thought as an algebra for propositional logic: 1 for truth; 0 for falsehood; + for or; × for and; and − for not

England
1855 New York and Erie Railroad • plan and organization of the company, is more ‘radial’ than organization charts usually are, and has much of the organic feel that we find in many mind maps: England
1870 John Tyndall "Scientific Use of the Imagination" England
1872 Augustus De Morgan "Budget of Paradoxes" • numerical syllogism - "shows how easily traditional class logic slides over into arithmetic." [1] England
1874 William Stanley Jevons "Principles of Science" England
 
1879 Gottlob Frege • used tree diagrams for representing first-order-logic, but nobody else adopted his notation German
1880 John Venn "On the Diagrammatic and Mechanical Representation of Propositions and Reasonings", Philosophical Magazine • it was not the first use of such representation, however he comprehensively surveyed and formalized their usage, and was the first to generalize them. England
1880 Charles Sanders Peirce "On the algebra of logic", American Journal of Mathematics 3, 15-57 • assertional networks USA
1881 John Venn "Symbolic Logic" England
1883 Francis H Bradley "The Principles of Logic" England
1889 John Venn "Principles of Empirical Logic" England
1870 Charles S Peirce
• added n-adic relations to Boolean algebra USA
1880 Charles S Peirce • introduced quantifiers USA
1885 Charles S Peirce "On the algebra of logic", American Journal of Mathematics 7 • extended the algebraic notation to both first-order and higher-order logic  USA
1889 Giuseppe Peano "Aritmetices principia nova methoda exposita" • adopted Peirce’s algebra and changed some of the symbols to create the modern notation for predicate calculus.

Italy
1896 Charles S Peirce • invented existential graphs (EGs) as a more diagrammatic notation for "the atoms and molecules of logic."
1897 Wilhelm M Wundt "Outlines of psychology" • memory-image German
1886 Lewis Carroll "The Game of Logic" England
1894 Heinrich Hertz
German
1896 Lewis Carroll "Symbolic Logic" •  England
1899 Ludwig Boltzmann German
 
1904 Richard Semon "Die mnemischen Empfindungen in ihren Beziehungen zu den Originalempfindungen" • development of the engram theory of memory German
 
1913 Otto Selz • executable network include some mechanism, such as marker passing or attached procedures, which can perform inferences, pass messages, or search for patterns and associations German
1913 Charles C Trowbridge "On fundamental methods of orientation and imaginary", Science Vol. 38, Issue 990 • imaginary maps USA
1922 Ludwig Wittgenstein "Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus" German
1923 Jean Piaget • introduces schema Swiss
1924 Jacques Raverat • mind mapping-like structuring (described in a letter to Virginia Woolf) [2] French
1925 Alfred Korzybski • "structural differential" patent for a physical chart or three-dimensional model illustrating the abstracting processes of the human nervous system Polish
1931 Charles Williams"The Place of the Lion" • early suggestive of visual mapping [2] England
1932 Edward Lee Thorndike "The Fundamentals of Learning" • developed a stimulus-response theory, which he called connectionism [3] USA
1936 Kurt Lewin "Principles of  Topological Psychology" German/ USA


1940 Jean-Paul Sartre "The Imaginary: A phenomenological psychology of the imagination" • review of the literature
• critics Bergson’s work
French
 

 

 
 
1943 Kenneth Craik "The Nature of Explanation" England
1943 Warren McCulloch & Walter Pitts
• learning networks
• designed a theoretical model of neural nets that are capable of learning and computing any Boolean function of their inputs [3]


 
1948 Edward C Tolman "Cognitive maps in rats and men". Psychological Review. 55 (4) • proposed that rats use cognitive maps to navigate French
1950 Arthur W Melton, "Learning", Annual Review of Psychology I, 9-3 • cognitive maps
 
1956 Richard H Richens "Preprogramming for mechanical translation", Mechanical Translation 3:1 • introduces semantic nets for computers as an "interlingua" for machine translation of natural languages, "in which all the structural peculiarities of the base language are removed and we are left with what I shall call a ‘semantic net’ of ‘naked ideas’.
1957 Walt Disney
• business map (concept map-like)
1958 Frank Rosenblatt "The perceptron: a probabilistic model for information storage and organization in the brain", Psychological Review 65:6 • built a machine called a perceptron, which simulated the nodes and links of a neural net [3]
1961 Margaret Masterman "Semantic message detection for machine translation, using an interlingua, in NPL" • "developed a list of 100 primitive concept types, such as Folk, Stuff, Thing, Do, and Be. She organized the concept types in a lattice, which permits inheritance from multiple supertypes"
1963 Robert F Simmons "Synthetic language behavior", Data Processing Management. 5 (12):
1963 David Ausubel "The psychology of meaningful verbal learning"
1964 Carl G Jung "Man and His Symbols"
1964 David Hays • presented dependency theory as a formal alternative to Chomsky’s syntactic notations
1968 Evelyn Wood Reading Dynamics course • used a technique resembling mind mapping [2]
1967 M. R Quillian "Word concepts: A theory and simulation of some basic semantic capabilities", Behavioral Science 12(5)
1969 Allan M. Collins; M. R. Quillian "Retrieval time from semantic memory", Journal of verbal learning and verbal behavior 8(2)
1971 M Buckley Hanf "Mapping: A technique for translating reading into thinking", Journal of Reading 14
1974 Tony Buzan "Use your head" • introduces mind maps (further books follow)
1975 Marvin Minsky "A Framework for the Representation of Knowledge" • introduces the representation of common sense knowledge via frames
1976 John F Sowa "Conceptual Structures: Information Processing in Mind and Machine" • introduces conceptual graph
1976 Chuck Rieger • introduces implicational networks: "use implication as the primary relation for connecting nodes. They may be used to represent patterns of beliefs, causality, or inferences. That way it is also called belief networks, causal networks, Bayesian networks, or truth-maintenance system."
 
1976 • introduces entity-relationship model (ERM)
1976 Richard Dawkins  "The Selfish Gene" • coins meme as "unit of information residing in the brain and is the mutating replicator in human cultural evolution"
 
 
1976 Joseph D Novak • introduces frame semantics
1977 Joseph D Novak "A Theory of Education"
1978 Joseph D Novak • connections
1978 Joseph D Novak • advance organizers revisited
1979 J Stewart et al "Concept maps: A tool for use in biology teaching" The American Biology Teacher, 41(3),
 

1979 Joseph D Novak "Applying psychology and philosophy to the improvement of laboratory teaching", The American Biology Teacher, 41(8)
 
1980 Joseph D Novak "Learning theory applied to the biology classroom", The American Biology Teacher, 42(5)
1980 Brian Wilson "Systems: Concepts, methodologies and Applications"
1980 Glenn Freedman, Elizabeth G. Reynolds "Enriching Basal Reader Lessons with Semantic Webbing" The Reading Teacher 33 (6)
1981 Peter Checkland "Systems Thinking, Systems Practice"
1983 Philip Johnson-Laird "Mental Models: Towards a Cognitive Science of Language, Inference and Consciousness"
1983 Brachman • hybrid networks: combine two or more of the previous techniques, either in a single network or in separate, but closely interacting networks
1981 Craig J Cleland "Highlighting Issues in Children's Literature through Semantic Webbing" The Reading Teacher 33(6)
1983 Dedre Gentner & Albert Stevens • edited a collection of chapters in a book titled "Mental Models"
1987 John F Sowa "Semantic Networks"
1984 Joseph D Novak & B Gowin "Learning how to learn"
1998 Joseph D Novak "Learning, creating, and using knowledge: Concept Maps as Facilitative Tools in Schools and Corporations"
 
1998 Richard C Anderson.
• schema theory
1991 Richard Dawkins "Viruses of the Mind" [essay] • uses memetics to explain the phenomenon of religious belief and the various characteristics of organized religions
 
 
 
 

References:
[1] Martin Gardner (1958) Logic Machines and Diagrams
[2] The Mind Mapping () Roots of Visual Mapping (link)
[3] Manuel Lima (2014) The Book of Trees: Visualizing branches of Knowledge
[4]

No comments:

Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...